Investing/Nov 21 edition/Reporting & analysis
RegulationMarkets

RegulationRules, enforcement & market structure

SEC Proposes Taking Direct Control of the Consolidated Audit Trail, With Costs Funded Through Appropriations

The SEC proposed repealing Rule 613 and adopting Rule 17a-26. The change would move the Consolidated Audit Trail from exchange and FINRA control to the agency or its designee, and Congress would fund it instead of industry fees. Reporting obligations stay largely unchanged.

From the SEC · Press releases article of November 20, 2026 and cited sources: The Nov. 20 proposal changes who runs and pays for the CAT. [1]

SOURCES[1] SEC press release 2026-117 sec.gov

AI-assisted, not human-edited. Methodology Corrections Who owns this site

KEY FACTS
What happened
The Nov. 20 proposal changes who runs and pays for the CAT. [1]
Original source
SEC · Press releases article, company source
Brief by
AT Pulse research desk AI-assisted; publisher and contact on the desk page
When
November 20, 2026 article published
Evidence
9 sources across 8 sites

Reach: not measured yet

U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission Press Release
Image: U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission — Original article ↗
THE CORE IDEAS4 TAKEAWAYS
01

The Nov. 20 proposal changes who runs and pays for the CAT. Exchanges, FINRA and broker-dealers would report to the SEC or a designee it selects. SEC appropriations would cover the costs, replacing the fee model run through the CAT NMS Plan. Comments are open for 60 days after Federal Register publication. [1]

02

Firms would report substantially the same data required today, so existing reporting pipelines should mostly carry over. Personal identifying information stays excluded. Earlier cost cuts and exemptive relief, much of it temporary until now, would be folded into the new rule. [1] [3]

03

Cost figures differ. Chairman Atkins cites nearly $250 million a year, which matches the 2025 peak of about $248 million. Reported 2026 budgets range from about $137 million to $156 million. The SEC's own projection of more than $100 million in yearly savings from earlier changes has not been independently audited. [2] [3] [5] [6]

04

The proposal follows the Eleventh Circuit's July 2025 decision striking down the 2023 CAT funding order, an April 2026 concept release seeking broad comment, and a July push from SIFMA for the SEC to run and fund the CAT itself. [3] [4] [5]

WHY IT MATTERS

The proposal targets ownership and funding, not data collection. As a result, broker-dealers could stop paying CAT fees but would keep their reporting duties. CAT spending would also become subject to annual congressional budget decisions.

Sources are gathered, including SEC primary documents, SIFMA, Katten, Commissioner Peirce and news coverage. Writing the dossier now.

Executive brief

The SEC wants to take direct control of the Consolidated Audit Trail (CAT), the central database of U.S. equity and options orders and trades. Today it is run by the exchanges and FINRA. Congress, through SEC appropriations, would pay the agency's CAT costs instead of the industry fees used now. On Nov. 20, 2026 the SEC proposed repealing Rule 613 and adding a new Rule 17a-26, under which firms would report largely the same data to the SEC or a firm it picks (SEC). Chairman Atkins says CAT costs grew to nearly $250 million a year (Atkins statement).

What changed and event timeline

  1. CAT NMS Plan approved

    The SEC first estimated yearly operating costs at about $55.8 million. By 2025 they were above $248 million ().

  2. Court strikes down the funding order

    The Eleventh Circuit threw out the SEC's 2023 CAT Funding Order, which unsettled how CAT costs are split ().

  3. Concept release opens a broad review

    The SEC asked for comment on regulatory needs, privacy, cheaper technology and cybersecurity. Comments were due June 22 ().

  4. SIFMA calls for SEC control

    The broker-dealer trade group said the SEC should scrap the CAT NMS Plan, run the CAT itself and pay for it through its budget request ().

  5. Restructuring proposed

    The SEC proposed repealing Rule 613 and adding Rule 17a-26, with funding from appropriations. Comments are open for 60 days after the proposal appears in the Federal Register ().

Capabilities and access

  • Rules: Rule 613 of Regulation NMS would be repealed. New Rule 17a-26 under the Exchange Act would replace it (proposed rule, Release 34-106950).
  • Who reports: Exchanges, FINRA and broker-dealers.
  • Where data goes: To the SEC or a designee it chooses. The press release does not name a designee (SEC).
Read the full section
  • Rules: Rule 613 of Regulation NMS would be repealed. New Rule 17a-26 under the Exchange Act would replace it (proposed rule, Release 34-106950).
  • Who reports: Exchanges, FINRA and broker-dealers. They would send "substantially the same" data required today under Rule 613, the CAT NMS Plan, SRO compliance rules and existing exemptions.
  • Where data goes: To the SEC or a designee it chooses. The press release does not name a designee (SEC).
  • What is excluded: Personally identifiable information (PII), which has already been permanently dropped from CAT reporting.

Technical analysis for researchers and developers

  • Ownership, not data model: The proposal changes who runs and pays for the system. The reporting obligations stay largely the same.
  • Exemptions become rules: Exemptive relief covering verbal floor activity, port-level settings and representative order linkage has mostly been temporary (NatLawReview).
  • Security work still open: SIFMA wants the SEC to return to its 2020 data-security proposal and limit bulk downloads of CAT data (SIFMA).
Read the full section
  • Ownership, not data model: The proposal changes who runs and pays for the system. The reporting obligations stay largely the same. Firms' reporting pipelines should mostly carry over, but they would be governed by an SEC rule rather than plan-specific SRO compliance rules (SEC).
  • Exemptions become rules: Exemptive relief covering verbal floor activity, port-level settings and representative order linkage has mostly been temporary (NatLawReview). The proposal says it would include the cost cuts and PII removal already made.
  • Security work still open: SIFMA wants the SEC to return to its 2020 data-security proposal and limit bulk downloads of CAT data (SIFMA).

Claims and evidence

The $250 million figure appears to be the peak, not today's cost.

Read the full section
  • Over $100 million in projected yearly savings from earlier exemptions and amendments. This comes from the SEC itself (SEC). No independent audit of the figure turned up.
  • Current costs: sources disagree. Atkins cites "nearly $250 million" a year (statement). Other figures:
  • $147 million budget for 2026, as of March (SIFMA)
  • About $156 million budget for 2026 (Katten)
  • $137 million, down about 45% since 2024 (aggregated news report, rallies.ai)

The $250 million figure appears to be the peak, not today's cost.

  • Support from investors and market participants for more SEC control. The SEC reports this. SIFMA's comments back it up (Traders Magazine).

Context and prior work

The CAT lets regulators reconstruct how orders are placed, routed and executed across equity and options markets. It has been run by an entity overseen by FINRA (rallies.ai). SIFMA says the first cost estimates were $36–56 million a year.

Read the full section

The CAT lets regulators reconstruct how orders are placed, routed and executed across equity and options markets. It has been run by an entity overseen by FINRA (rallies.ai). SIFMA says the first cost estimates were $36–56 million a year. It argues the setup creates bad incentives: broker-dealers pay most of the bill but have no say in governance, while the SEC, the main user, has little reason to hold down spending (SIFMA).

Limitations, safety and contested findings

  • Privacy concerns remain. Commissioner Peirce calls the CAT a government-mandated record of every equity and options order.
  • Paying from appropriations makes CAT costs part of the yearly congressional budget process (rallies.ai).
  • No commission vote count, designee or transition schedule was found in the reviewed sources (Finadium).
Read the full section
  • Privacy concerns remain. Commissioner Peirce calls the CAT a government-mandated record of every equity and options order. She argues that removing PII and cutting costs do not fix the surveillance design (Peirce via Harvard Law Forum). Since the proposal keeps largely the same data, that objection still applies.
  • Funding risk. Paying from appropriations makes CAT costs part of the yearly congressional budget process (rallies.ai).
  • Gaps. No commission vote count, designee or transition schedule was found in the reviewed sources (Finadium).

Business and practitioner implications

  • Broker-dealers: They could stop paying CAT fees, but their reporting duties would continue under Rule 17a-26 (SEC).
  • Exchanges and FINRA: They would lose control of governance. FINRA's current operating role could change depending on which designee the SEC picks.
  • Compliance and data engineering teams: Expect the formats to stay largely the same but the rulebook to change.
Read the full section
  • Broker-dealers: They could stop paying CAT fees, but their reporting duties would continue under Rule 17a-26 (SEC).
  • Exchanges and FINRA: They would lose control of governance. FINRA's current operating role could change depending on which designee the SEC picks.
  • Compliance and data engineering teams: Expect the formats to stay largely the same but the rulebook to change. Watch for the designee, the transition schedule and any limits on data access.
  • Deadline: Comments are due 60 days after Federal Register publication.
  • Market impact: None of the reviewed sources report a market price reaction. This is a rule proposal, not a change in fundamentals.
FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE

The source trail.

Sources (9)
A LITTLE LESS NOISE. A LOT MORE CONTEXT.

Stay curious.
Follow the evidence.

Independent perspectives, the original sources, and room for the questions that don't have easy answers.

How we build the brief
Connect with us

Find us where you already read.