Fed & ratesCentral banks & interest rates
Barry Knapp Compares the Fed's Renewed Rate Hikes to 2018 as S&P 500 Earnings Growth Eases From 31%
On Excess Returns, Ironsides' Barry Knapp likens the Fed's renewed tightening to 2018. He argues that hikes hit banks, homebuilders and small firms while a large Fed balance sheet keeps big borrowers' funding cheap. S&P 500 profit growth remains near 30%.
From the Excess Returns podcast episode of November 18, 2026 and cited sources: Knapp's central claim is about who feels tighter policy. [1] [4] [10]
SOURCES[1] The Fed Is Hiking. Earnings Growth Is Slowing. Is This… podcasters.spotify.com[4] Ironsides: The Stretch Run: 2018 Looms Large ironsidesmacro.substack.com[10] Fox Business/Reuters: Powell's approach sets up rocky 2019 foxbusiness.com
AI-assisted, not human-edited. Methodology Corrections Who owns this site
- Original source
- Excess Returns podcast episode, independent perspective
- Brief by
- AT Pulse research desk AI-assisted; publisher and contact on the desk page
- When
- November 18, 2026 podcast episode published
- Covered
- Nov 19 edition
- Evidence
- 12 sources across 9 sites; no transcript
- 1The Fed Is Hiking. Earnings Growth Is Slowing. Is This…podcasters.spotify.com
- 2FactSet earnings season update, Nov 6, 2026insight.factset.com
- 3Fox Business: Fed hikes for first time since 2023foxbusiness.com
- 4Ironsides: The Stretch Run: 2018 Looms Largeironsidesmacro.substack.com
- 5investingLive: October 2026 FOMC statementinvestinglive.com
- 6Federal Reserve FOMC statement, Oct 28, 2026federalreserve.gov
Reach: not measured yet
Knapp's central claim is about who feels tighter policy. Higher short-term rates squeeze floating-rate and bank-dependent borrowers, such as homebuilders, banks and smaller firms. Meanwhile, the Fed's large bond holdings keep long-term financing cheaper for big issuers. He argues this mix makes 2018, when the Fed kept tightening as earnings growth cooled, the relevant precedent. One difference he criticizes is that the Fed is not described as shrinking its balance sheet now, as it was in 2018. [1] [4] [10]
The claim that earnings growth is slowing holds only in a narrow sense. S&P 500 blended earnings growth was 31.4% in Q3, and Q4 estimates are 28.4%. However, companies beat estimates by an average of 2.7%, the smallest margin since Q4 2022. The forward P/E of 17.7 sits below its 5- and 10-year averages. [2]
Policy has turned hawkish. On September 16 the FOMC raised rates by 25bp to 3.75–4.00%, its first hike since 2023. On October 28 it held rates on a 10–2 vote, with two dissenters favouring another hike. October CPI rose 0.4%, or 0.3% excluding food and energy. No year-over-year figure was published because October 2025 data was never collected. The reasons for higher long-term yields are disputed: Knapp points to the expected Fed path, while Chair Warsh cited economic strength, corporate demand for capital and geopolitics. [3] [4] [5] [6] [8]
Data show tightening resumed while profits and AI spending remain strong. Knapp's argument that pressure concentrates on bank-dependent borrowers and eventually on AI financing is one analyst's untested view.
Read the full assessment
November CPI and the December FOMC projections are the next tests.
Executive brief
The episode's title says earnings growth is slowing, but S&P 500 profits are still growing fast. FactSet put Q3 2026 blended earnings growth at 31.4% and Q4 estimates at 28.4%, so growth is easing slightly from a very high level (FactSet). In the Excess Returns episode recorded November 16, 2026, Barry Knapp of Ironsides Macroeconomics compares today to 2018, when the Fed kept tightening while earnings growth slowed. He argues that rate hikes squeeze small businesses, banks and homebuilders, while the Fed's large bond holdings keep financing cheap for big borrowers (episode page). This report states no investment view.
What changed and event timeline
First Fed hike since 2023
The FOMC voted unanimously to raise rates 25bp to 3.75–4.00%. Fed Chair Kevin Warsh said inflation is too high and has been for too long. The 10-year Treasury yield was near 5% ().
Knapp says "2018 looms large."
In his newsletter, Knapp called the Fed's hawkish turn the main driver of higher long-term rates. He named housing as "Ground Zero" and flagged leverage in data-center financing ().
Fed holds, with two hawkish dissents
The FOMC kept rates at 3.75–4.00% on a 10–2 vote. Governor Lisa Cook and Cleveland Fed President Beth Hammack wanted another 25bp hike (;).
AI capex is still rising
Amazon, Alphabet, Meta, Microsoft and SpaceX together spent about $227B on capex in Q3, roughly 20% more than in Q2. All five signalled higher spending in 2027 ().
Profit growth is strong but surprises are shrinking
Q3 earnings growth was 31.4%. Companies beat estimates by an average of only 2.7%, the smallest beat since Q4 2022. The forward P/E was 17.7 ().
October inflation stays firm
Consumer prices rose 0.4% and core prices 0.3%. BLS could not publish a year-over-year rate because October 2025 data was never collected during the 2025 government shutdown ().
Capabilities and access
- Format: a roughly 60-minute Excess Returns interview, with Matt Zeigler as host and Knapp as guest.
- Topics by chapter: Fed balance sheet (13:31), labor-market churn (26:52), AI productivity (31:54), AI spending growth (36:31), sector positioning (48:13) and December projections (54:48).
- More of Knapp's research: Ironsides Substack.
Read the full section
- Format: a roughly 60-minute Excess Returns interview, with Matt Zeigler as host and Knapp as guest. It was recorded November 16 and published November 18, 2026 (episode page).
- Topics by chapter: Fed balance sheet (13:31), labor-market churn (26:52), AI productivity (31:54), AI spending growth (36:31), sector positioning (48:13) and December projections (54:48).
- More of Knapp's research: Ironsides Substack.
Technical analysis for researchers and developers
- Mechanism: Knapp's core claim is about how policy reaches borrowers. The Fed's October statement only says it is keeping "ample reserves" (investingLive).
- Signals Knapp watches: credit spreads and capex relative to cash flow, as timing signals for stress in AI financing (Ironsides).
- Data caveat: without year-over-year CPI, inflation analysis has to rely on monthly changes (BLS).
Read the full section
- Mechanism: Knapp's core claim is about how policy reaches borrowers. Higher short-term rates hit floating-rate and bank-dependent borrowers, while the Fed's bond holdings keep long-term funding cheaper for large issuers (episode page). The Fed's October statement only says it is keeping "ample reserves" (investingLive).
- Signals Knapp watches: credit spreads and capex relative to cash flow, as timing signals for stress in AI financing (Ironsides).
- Data caveat: without year-over-year CPI, inflation analysis has to rely on monthly changes (BLS).
Claims and evidence
- "Earnings growth is slowing": only mildly supported.
- Why yields rose: this is disputed. Knapp attributes most of the rise to the expected Fed path (Ironsides).
- Pressure on AI capex growth: the quarterly reporting reviewed for this dossier shows spending still accelerating. Q3 rose about 20% from Q2 (HL).
Read the full section
- "Earnings growth is slowing": only mildly supported. Growth eases from 31.4% in Q3 to an estimated 28.4% in Q4, and earnings beats are the smallest since 2022 (FactSet).
- Why yields rose: this is disputed. Knapp attributes most of the rise to the expected Fed path (Ironsides). Warsh pointed to economic strength, corporate competition for capital and geopolitics (Fox Business).
- Pressure on AI capex growth: the quarterly reporting reviewed for this dossier shows spending still accelerating. Q3 rose about 20% from Q2 (HL).
- Labor churn, small-business stress: no independent data was found to support these points.
Context and prior work
- 2018: the Fed raised rates four times. At the December 2018 press conference, Powell described balance-sheet runoff as being on "automatic pilot."
- One key difference from 2018: the Fed is not described as shrinking its balance sheet. That is exactly the gap Knapp criticizes.
- Fed's September projections: core PCE inflation of 3.4% for 2026, a longer-run neutral rate of 3.25%, and a median of one more hike in 2026 (investingLive).
Read the full section
- 2018: the Fed raised rates four times. At the December 2018 press conference, Powell described balance-sheet runoff as being on "automatic pilot." The S&P 500 then fell almost 20% from its September peak by Christmas Eve (Fox Business/Reuters).
- One key difference from 2018: the Fed is not described as shrinking its balance sheet. That is exactly the gap Knapp criticizes.
- Fed's September projections: core PCE inflation of 3.4% for 2026, a longer-run neutral rate of 3.25%, and a median of one more hike in 2026 (investingLive).
Limitations, safety and contested findings
- The episode's arguments are summarized here from its published description and Knapp's newsletter.
- The 2018 comparison is contested.
- Inflation readings are less reliable than usual because the 2025 data gap removes year-over-year comparisons (BLS).
Read the full section
- The episode's arguments are summarized here from its published description and Knapp's newsletter. Those are one analyst's views, and no outside party has tested them.
- The 2018 comparison is contested. Earnings growth now is far stronger than the word "slowing" suggests, and the forward P/E of 17.7 is below its 5- and 10-year averages (FactSet).
- Inflation readings are less reliable than usual because the 2025 data gap removes year-over-year comparisons (BLS).
Business and practitioner implications
- AI infrastructure teams: funding conditions matter.
- Rate-sensitive borrowers: homebuilders, banks and smaller firms are where Knapp expects tightening to hit hardest (Ironsides).
- Next checkpoints: November CPI on December 10 (stockanalysis), then the December FOMC projections, which Knapp says may matter more than the rate decision itself.
Read the full section
- AI infrastructure teams: funding conditions matter. Knapp frames higher financing costs and cash flow as limits on how fast AI capex can keep growing, while companies are still guiding to higher spending in 2027 (HL).
- Rate-sensitive borrowers: homebuilders, banks and smaller firms are where Knapp expects tightening to hit hardest (Ironsides).
- Next checkpoints: November CPI on December 10 (stockanalysis), then the December FOMC projections, which Knapp says may matter more than the rate decision itself.
The source trail.
Sources (12)
The Fed Is Hiking. Earnings Growth Is Slowing. Is This 2018 Again? | Barry Knapp
Metadata only. Transcript unavailable: Audio transcription returned HTTP 429.
podcasters.spotify.com