StocksEquities, earnings & valuations
LSE study finds no statistically significant emissions drop in the three years after large companies set net zero targets
An LSE working paper finds net zero targets spread from about 70 to over 1,200 large listed firms between 2019 and 2024. Yet adopters' emissions fell only about 15% within three years, a decline too imprecise to separate from no effect.
From the Klement on Investing article of November 16, 2026 and cited sources: Net zero targets became the norm among large listed companies. [1] [5]
SOURCES[1] Klement on Investing – About those net zero targets klementoninvesting.substack.com[5] Net Zero Compare – Nearly two-thirds of largest listed… netzerocompare.com
AI-assisted, not human-edited. Methodology Corrections Who owns this site
- Original source
- Klement on Investing article, independent perspective
- Brief by
- AT Pulse research desk AI-assisted; publisher and contact on the desk page
- When
- November 16, 2026 article published
- Covered
- Nov 16 edition
- Evidence
- 10 sources across 8 sites
- 1Klement on Investing – About those net zero targetsklementoninvesting.substack.com
- 2LSE Grantham – Corporate net zero targets: have they…lse.ac.uk
- 3IDEAS/RePEc – CEPR DP 21441ideas.repec.org
- 4Trellis – Net zero stocktake: backtrackingtrellis.net
- 5Net Zero Compare – Nearly two-thirds of largest listed…netzerocompare.com
- 6GRI Working Paper 446 (PDF)lse.ac.uk
RisingHow it’s measured
Substack · 6 likes · 1 share
Reach blends public engagement (views, likes, comments, shares, stars) from the platforms where the story or its original source lives: YouTube, Hacker News, GitHub, Substack and similar. A video and the article written from its transcript share one score, taken from the video. Platforms with no data are left out rather than counted as zero, and the age of a story never lowers its score.

Net zero targets became the norm among large listed companies. About 70 of roughly 2,000 firms had one at the end of 2019, and more than 1,200 had one by the end of 2024. Together those firms make up about two-thirds of the sample's market value, and most of their target dates fall between 2040 and 2050. A separate Net Zero Tracker count, 1,246 of 1,957 companies, is broadly consistent. [1] [5]
In the three years after setting a target, firms' absolute emissions were about 15% lower and their emissions intensity nearly 10% lower than those of non-adopters. Neither estimate is statistically significant. The authors describe the results as fitting gradual reductions but unable to rule out no effect. [1] [2] [9]
Adopting a target coincided with better forward-looking management practices. At the same time, firms without targets were catching up on basics such as disclosure, which narrows the measured gap between the two groups. The authors conclude that targets are neither pure greenwash nor a turning point. They fit best as one step in slow organisational change. [2] [3] [9]
The 2026 stocktake found that growth in new targets has stalled. Researchers reviewing 43 large target-holders saw signs of backtracking at 20 of them, though some revisions look like honest reassessments rather than retreat. Meanwhile, 78% of companies with targets now publish implementation plans, up from 69% in 2025. [4] [5]
net zero pledges are now mainstream, but they show no statistically clear effect on emissions in the near term. Implication: interim targets, implementation plans and measured emissions trends likely tell investors more than the pledge alone.
Executive brief
The share of large listed companies with net zero targets rose from 70 of roughly 2,000 at the end of 2019 to more than 1,200 by the end of 2024. Those companies make up about two-thirds of the sample's market value. In the three years after setting a target, their emissions fell by about 15% on average, but that drop is not statistically significant. The numbers come from an LSE working paper by Simon Dietz and Nikolaus Hastreiter, as described by Klement on Investing. The authors conclude that targets are neither pure greenwash nor a turning point. They fit best as one step in slow organisational change.
What changed and event timeline
- End-2019: Few targets
Only about 70 of roughly 2,000 global large-cap firms had long-term net zero targets, according to the Dietz–Hastreiter data as summarised by.
- Context
End-2024: Targets become the norm
More than 1,200 firms had targets, covering about two-thirds of the sample's combined market cap. Most target dates fall between 2040 and 2050 ().
LSE working paper published
Grantham Research Institute Working Paper 446 reports "little evidence" that adopting a target leads to large or immediate emissions cuts ().
CEPR discussion paper
The same study appears as a CEPR discussion paper using difference-in-differences and event-study methods ().
5–6 November 2026: Net Zero Stocktake 2026
Net Zero Tracker counted 1,246 of 1,957 listed companies with targets. It found that growth in new targets has stalled, though there is little sign of companies abandoning them wholesale (;).
Commentary
Klement argues that the effects point the right way but are too weak to show that targets have cut emissions so far ().
Capabilities and access
- The study: "Corporate net zero targets: have they achieved anything?" by Dietz and Hastreiter.
- Status: It is a working paper and has not been peer-reviewed.
- Companion data: Net Zero Tracker's Net Zero Stocktake tracks target status and how good the targets are.
Read the full section
- The study: "Corporate net zero targets: have they achieved anything?" by Dietz and Hastreiter. It is free to read as GRI Working Paper 446 (PDF), as CEPR DP 21441, and in a GRASFI conference version.
- Status: It is a working paper and has not been peer-reviewed.
- Companion data: Net Zero Tracker's Net Zero Stocktake tracks target status and how good the targets are.
Technical analysis for researchers and developers
- Design: The study compares firms that adopted targets with firms that did not, before and after adoption.
- Outcomes measured: Absolute emissions and emissions intensity (emissions relative to business size).
- Why the average effect looks weak: Companies without targets are catching up on basic practices such as disclosure, which shrinks the measured gap between the two groups (LSE Grantham).
Read the full section
- Design: The study compares firms that adopted targets with firms that did not, before and after adoption. It uses difference-in-differences and event-study methods across several datasets on emissions and corporate climate practices (IDEAS/RePEc; LSE Grantham).
- Outcomes measured: Absolute emissions and emissions intensity (emissions relative to business size). At year 3, the estimates are about −15% and nearly −10%, and neither is significant (Klement on Investing).
- Why the average effect looks weak: Companies without targets are catching up on basic practices such as disclosure, which shrinks the measured gap between the two groups (LSE Grantham).
- Gaps in the summaries: The reviewed summaries do not name the specific estimator, the emissions scopes covered, or the exact sample window.
Claims and evidence
- Claim: targets surged from 70 to over 1,200 firms between 2019 and 2024. This comes from the paper's data via Klement.
- Claim: emissions fall after adoption, but not significantly. The authors themselves call their estimates imprecise (LSE Grantham).
- Claim: forward-looking management practices improve around the time of adoption. This is the authors' finding (IDEAS/RePEc).
Read the full section
- Claim: targets surged from 70 to over 1,200 firms between 2019 and 2024. This comes from the paper's data via Klement. It roughly matches Net Zero Tracker's separate count of 1,246 of 1,957 companies (Net Zero Compare).
- Claim: emissions fall after adoption, but not significantly. The authors themselves call their estimates imprecise (LSE Grantham).
- Claim: forward-looking management practices improve around the time of adoption. This is the authors' finding (IDEAS/RePEc).
- Corroboration: No independent replication of the emissions estimates turned up in the reviewed sources.
Context and prior work
- Earlier stocktake: By September 2025, Net Zero Tracker found 1,935 of 4,083 tracked entities had net zero targets.
- Target-setting in 2025: The Science Based Targets initiative reported that corporate target-setting rose 40% in 2025, with Asia growing fastest (SBTi).
- Earlier post in the series: Klement frames this piece after an earlier one on companies scaling back public communication about DEI programmes (Klement on Investing).
Read the full section
- Earlier stocktake: By September 2025, Net Zero Tracker found 1,935 of 4,083 tracked entities had net zero targets. It also said that few of those targets meet minimum integrity standards (Net Zero Stocktake 2025).
- Target-setting in 2025: The Science Based Targets initiative reported that corporate target-setting rose 40% in 2025, with Asia growing fastest (SBTi).
- Earlier post in the series: Klement frames this piece after an earlier one on companies scaling back public communication about DEI programmes (Klement on Investing).
Limitations, safety and contested findings
- Imprecise estimates: The emissions estimates fit a pattern of gradual reductions but cannot rule out no effect (LSE Grantham).
- Short window: Most targets were set after 2020, so the evidence covers only a few years after adoption.
- Backtracking: Net Zero Tracker researchers reported signs of backtracking at 20 of 43 large target-holders they reviewed, including 11 of 18 financial firms.
Read the full section
- Imprecise estimates: The emissions estimates fit a pattern of gradual reductions but cannot rule out no effect (LSE Grantham).
- Short window: Most targets were set after 2020, so the evidence covers only a few years after adoption.
- Backtracking: Net Zero Tracker researchers reported signs of backtracking at 20 of 43 large target-holders they reviewed, including 11 of 18 financial firms. They also say some revisions are honest reassessments rather than retreat (Trellis).
- Plans are improving: 78% of companies with targets now publish implementation plans, up from 69% in 2025, which complicates a simple "greenwash" reading (Net Zero Compare).
Business and practitioner implications
- For investors and analysts: A net zero pledge is a weak signal of near-term emissions on its own (LSE Grantham).
- For corporate leaders: The study links targets to better strategic management practices, not to immediate cuts.
- Regional differences: The share of US companies with targets slipped from 52% to 51%. China's rose to 28%, and the EU's reached 85% (Trellis).
Read the full section
- For investors and analysts: A net zero pledge is a weak signal of near-term emissions on its own (LSE Grantham). Interim targets, implementation plans and measured emissions trends carry more information.
- For corporate leaders: The study links targets to better strategic management practices, not to immediate cuts. Boards should expect any emissions benefit to take time to show up.
- Regional differences: The share of US companies with targets slipped from 52% to 51%. China's rose to 28%, and the EU's reached 85% (Trellis). Policy settings appear to shape adoption more than the pledges themselves do.
- None of this is investment advice.